The MGM DVD of
When Harry Met Sally proves that the film keeps improving with age. The template for modern studio romantic comedies,
When Harry Met Sally is also head and shoulders above its many imitators (including those of star
Meg Ryan and writer
Nora Ephron). Besides showing off the film's considerable charms, the DVD comes loaded with extra features and has been spruced up for the digital age. A better-than-average "making-of" documentary points out that the genesis of the film was director
Rob Reiner's own dating woes and the friendly personality differences between himself and screenwriter
Nora Ephron. The documentary is breezy but does show how many people contributed to the success of the movie and how easily it all could have gone off track. Also included are a number of scenes that were deleted from the finished film and a pretty thorough audio commentary from Reiner. The funny deleted scenes go over better than Reiner's commentary, which is informative but proves once again that
Mel Brooks is one of the few people who can be entertaining while explaining comedy. The Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround audio track lives up to the theatrical release and the excellent anamorphic widescreen transfer showcases
Barry Sonnenfeld's superb lensing. Though
When Harry Met Sally is sometimes viewed as
Woody Allen for the masses, this DVD reaffirms that it ended up creating a world and viewpoint all its own. ~ Nick Dedina, All Movie Guide