Midway was a good idea for a movie that, at least in its feature film release, was very poorly executed. The notion probably didn't seem bad -- take newsreel footage, shots from old Hollywood films, and integrate a story about a past event with a current all-star cast.
Irwin Allen, who'd broken box office records around the world with
The Poseidon Adventure, had been doing it for years on television and in movies, He had become a respected producer, and Universal had practically secured the patent on all-star blockbusters at the dawn of the 1970s with
Airport. The problem was that, apart from a handful of performances, everyone in the film is so straitjacketed by their roles that they're mostly left parroting hopeless war movie cliches.
Henry Fonda,
Glenn Ford, and
Hal Holbrook do well enough, but the rest of the big-name cast is practically sleepwalking. The "drama" surrounding
Charlton Heston in the theatrical version of the film (the one on this DVD) is a pale rewrite of the
John Wayne/
Brandon de Wilde subplot from
In Harm's Way, with a racial/romantic twist included. Between trying to recreate events spread over an entire ocean and four months of interlocking decisions,
Midway comes off as virtually a TV movie when compared to
In Harm's Way. Even
John Williams' score is laden with little musical clichés. Ironically, there is a better version of this film -- the network television cut, which includes ten minutes of footage from the Battle of the Coral Sea (which takes place offscreen in this version) and a performance-enhancing romantic subplot for Heston's character (a totally fictional officer) and that of
Susan Sullivan (which appears nowhere in this edition). The only thing that saves the shorter version of the film is the import of the subject itself -- the film offers a good measure of suspense once the Japanese launch their planes; the pacing picks up, and the plot rests with those planes rather than with the actors. The DVD itself is a decent job. The 2.35 aspect ratio preserves the Panavision theatrical image, and the sound even in the dramatic scenes is not only loud (though the original release's "Sensurround" is nowhere in evidence), but has a pleasing dimensionality about it. The image quality is excellent, and only the relative blandness of the military aircraft keeps this from being one of the easier-on-the-eye blockbusters of its period. The clarity of the image is a major drawback in one respect, because it is amazingly easy to spot the footage lifted from
Tora! Tora! Tora! and inserted into scenes of the attack on Midway's air field. No trailer or any other special features are present, and the movie starts automatically unless one goes to the menu, which is lively enough, with boxes containing moving images from the relevant opening scenes of each chapter. ~ Bruce Eder, All Movie Guide