Sol Lesser's production of
Our Town, directed by
Sam Wood and designed by
William Cameron Menzies, comes to DVD in about the best presentation that the 1940 movie has had in decades -- which isn't to say that it's perfect, but it is superior to any of the totally unauthorized, public domain video or television presentations that the movie received in the 1980s. The producers claim to have used original negative elements as the source for their transfer, and image is clean and reasonably sharp -- it is not really comparable, however, in either consistency of contrast or sharpness, to such black-and-white movies of similar vintage as, say,
Citizen Kane or
The Magnificent Ambersons. What's more, one can spot a missing frame here and there, and the audio is compressed more than is ideal, which leads one to question what source there was on that front. Still, once one gets past those mild limitations on the source, the DVD is absorbing in its presentation; the movie was one of the most carefully, subtly, and elaborately designed of its period, and it is an intense viewing experience in what, for a change, is a better-than-decent source. The sound compression and the low volume level do take their toll on
Aaron Copland's music, but it's possible to make adjustments for this problem, and overall, short of a major restoration effort (assuming that better elements do exist), this is as good as this special film is ever likely to look or sound. Focus Films' DVD opens automatically on a two-layer menu that allows one easy access to the film itself, and then a whole raft of bonus materials. The most closely associated with the movie itself is the 52-minute Lux Radio Theater audio dramatization of the screenplay, featuring the principal members of the movie's cast (and the happy ending permitted by author
Thornton Wilder). Also present is the 1930 fantasy short film The Wizard's Apprentice, which was reportedly part of the inspiration for
Walt Disney's
Fantasia, and whose only connection to
Our Town is as an earlier showcase of
William Cameron Menzies' production technique. Perhaps the most interesting of the extras is the 1943 short film The Town, directed by
Josef von Sternberg, which is a documentary about a typical Midwestern town, a sort of real-life statistical answer to
Our Town with its own artfulness in its visuals and editing. There is a certain wartime veneer to the narrative, as one would expect, and it's almost as revealing here in what isn't depicted -- like very many non-white faces -- as what is, but the idea was a good one. Thus, this DVD is packed with material, having to do in greater or lesser degree with key elements and themes resounding in the main feature -- it's rather a bargain overall, and difficult to resist. ~ Bruce Eder, All Movie Guide