S A A. (Learned2Heal) wrote on 1/4/2009...
2 of 3 member(s) found this review helpful.
A true masterpiece, this movie. It will have you on the edge of your seat throughout. Amazing character development and acting. No surprise that, from Philip Seymour Hoffman and Albert Finney. The real surprise was Ethan Hawke who, to me, always seemed an overrated mediocre actor. He was unbelievably good in this!
The plot of this film is fairly original and deserved the nominations for Best Original Screenplay, but the presentation is what makes it really work. There should have been an award for the editing too. The score ratcheted up the suspense nicely too.
The whole story comes together flawlessly, at its own prescribed pace. You may not feel much for the characters, but you don't have to. It merely shows you how seemingly ordinary people can get themselves into extraordinarily bad situations just by a slight miscalculation or two. They think they have this plan all sewn up, no problem. So simple. A cakewalk really. All too human... And so are their reactions when it all goes horribly wrong.
I gave it 4 stars. IMDB gives it 7.4/10.
Mary C. (librariansrule) wrote on 12/28/2008...
2 of 3 member(s) found this review helpful.
As has been said, this film was beautifully done. The characters were 3-dimensional, the plot was never heavy-handed, always believable. The pay off at the end was excellent, and--for me--the point of the whole film. Everything was right on the money. That said, I doubt if I will watch it more than once. I don't necessarily need heroes and villains in a movie, I like real people rather than cardboard figures.....but once was enough with this group.
Danielle T. (sugarkane) from FITCHBURG, WI wrote on 10/23/2008...
5 of 6 member(s) found this review helpful.
This was an interesting story, no doubt. And, it was beautifully directed and acted. My only problem with this movie is that every character was deplorable, and I found myself asking "who am I rooting for?" The anwser was, sadly, no one. Worth a watch, and a solid three stars, but not my fave movie of all time.