John Sturges's Sergeants Three (1962) was a staple on network television for much of the mid-1960's through the 1970's, and then it disappeared. Perhaps its absence, coupled with the rising appreciation for Sturges's work, helped the movie's reputation, which was never that great to begin with. Its reissue on DVD, letterboxed to its proper 2.35-to-1 aspect ratio (something it never offered on broadcast television) was considered a major event among fans of
Frank Sinatra,
Dean Martin,
Peter Lawford, and
Sammy Davis, Jr., the four stars. But as the disc reveals, it's little but a fairly good action-western, distinguished more for its cast and its source (
George Stevens' 1939
Gunga Din) than for anything that we see on the screen. The producers have tried to impart some value and significance to the movie by including a commentary track by
Frank Sinatra, Jr., who was a production assistant on the movie, but his work consists more of gee-whiz enthusiasm than any serious insights into the picture, its content, or its maker. Indeed, in the first three minutes of his audio track, he manages to mis-identify
John Sturges as the son of
Preston Sturges (the two were not related). In fact, the sheer superficiality and unfocused nature of his commentary only points up the movie's lightweight nature -- some pictures can carry a commentary track, and some can't, and this is one that shouldn't have been asked to. The only other bonus feature is a theatrical trailer. The disc opens automatically to a simple two-layer menu, which makes accessing (or shutting down) the audio commentary very easy. ~ Bruce Eder, All Movie Guide