Vanessa V. (sevenspiders) wrote on 9/16/2009...
1 of 1 member(s) found this review helpful.
My first impression of The Reader was Hugh Jackman's jaunty opening-song at the Oscars..."The Reader- I didn't see The Reader..." I was prepared for another overrated, uber-depressing Oscar drama about miserable people doing miserable things for the sake of being miserable. After that, a surprisingly touching, fast-paced and intrguing drama that raises legitimate questions about guilt, morality and responsibility was a pleasure and an astonishment.
Kate Winslet and Ralph Fiennes are fascinating and compulsively watchable, even with the most minimalist acting. Winslet is just enough of an enigma as the paradoxically sensual and aloof ex-Nazi. She is as sympathetic as a person who truly deserves to die can possibly be. Fiennes and the brilliant young David Kross together capture the before-during-after loss of innocence, much more emotional than physical, of the young man Winslet clings to in the post war days.
These characters are more honest than many. Their lives raise and acknowledge questions that really matter without any evasion- certainly this ex-Nazi deserves punishement, evil is evil whatever the circumstances that lead to it. But why just this one? Amidst a charged trial that reveals the atrocities Winslet's character was part of, she is one of a team to whom genocide was just a job. Circumstances single Winslet out as the ringleader- whether she was or not- and she shoulders the shared guilt for reasons of her own. Justice is at once served and escaped.
Much has been said of the sexual relationship between the two characters at the beginning. Certainly this is a movie for adults, and opening scenes are as frank and honest about two people's enjoyment of each other and irritations with each other, as the later scenes are about injustices and atrocities. They are frank and explicit, but not unnecessary or gratuitous.
The Reader is a very rare movie, one of the quietest films of the decade but one whose whispers stay with you long after the final credits.
Suzanne B. wrote on 6/13/2009...
Kate Winslet is astoundingly good in this film about a cold-hearted German woman who has an inappropriate sexual relationship with a teenager and how their lives intersect again many years later. Winslet portrays a character who is a moral vaccuum, and she plays it to perfection.