Frank E. (realartist) from HENDERSONVLLE, NC wrote on 8/31/2009...
This movie may be getting 3 stars since it IS an unusual, and slightly disturbing story. A young girl returns to the art colony in a gorgeous section of Italy to an art colony where her mother once stayed, and where she also had visited when younger. Now she is 19, and never been with a man; and is hoping for a nice summer romance to end her virginity.
In most movies, there is usually a 'bad guy' or dark force at work for our hero, or heroine to overcome. But in this movie, the dark force is the artist colony with a lot of young people around living the 'free love without commitment' lifestyle. A number of men are competing to be the one to take Lucy's virginity. Almost all of them are just womanizers, with no morals or scruples at all.
As a theologian, I can assure you that a group of 'church folk' would all walk out in an indignant huff. But this is the unflattering aspect of church folk, inasmuch as there seems to be an attempt to "establish that WE are ABOVE sin"...when the simple fact is, all church folk have been like the people in this movie at one time in their life; are NOW sinners, and never will be above sin...never! So that would just be a big show and pretense of 'piety'..which makes everyone hate Christians. The honest thing to do is realize stuff that happens in this movie happens all day every day. Often young girls are thrown into these situations totally naive...not the brightest bulbs in the pack, so to speak.
So that gives you the 'tension' that underscores the movie..our worry about this poor naive young woman concerns us deeply.
Some of you guys out there might wince when your wife suggests a romance movie. That's unfortunate...for most romance stories have some pretty steamy sex scenes. This one has them all over the place..lots of bare breasts, and lots of ( cough ) fornicating. A bit shocking - so this worries us immensely. Many of these guys are not gentlemen at all.
What happens? Well, you'll just have to find out for yourself. I can tell you that this script is good...there are many scenes where the people are speaking in their native tongues...French, Italian, German...and no subtitles for it...so you feel as lost as Lucy does at times. This directorial technique is intended. There are many subtleties, and levels on which this story spins and diverts, taking aesthetic detours, arrives at dead ends, and takes you "by Robin Hood's Barn", so to speak...like real life. This directorial technique causes Lucy to be something like a rat in a maze.
It is a lovely story. Just relax and enjoy turning the pages. You won't perish in flames. After all..you've been through this yourselves, and came out alive, didn't you?
Although, if honest ~ you wonder how!