Of all
Robert Altman's early films released on DVD (
M*A*S*H,
Nashville), perhaps none was more anticipated than 1971's
McCabe & Mrs. Miller, starring
Warren Beatty and
Julie Christie. This was the esteemed director's revisionist anti-Western, part of his seemingly systematic deconstruction of genre throughout the 1970s ("I'm still chasing genres today,"
Altman says in the commentary track). Set in the bleak, rainy Pacific Northwest at the turn of the century, the film received critical accolades and was frequently singled out for its stunningly beautiful photography and difficult-to-decipher dialogue. If you've ever struggled through watching the darkly lit film on video or on TV, the Warner Home Video DVD will be a much-welcomed revelation. The 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen picture still exhibits some graininess and darkness, but that's to be expected given how the film was shot (using minimal and natural light) and the technique of "flashing" (very briefly exposing the negative to light in order to achieve an antiquated, sepia-like visual effect) that
Altman and his cinematographer
Vilmos Zsigmond employed. Many of the outdoor shots linger in the mind like paintings: McCabe (Beatty) crossing a bridge during the credit sequence, a church steeple rising into the sky at sunset, the snow-swept landscapes surrounding the growing town of Presbyterian Church, where McCabe establishes himself as proprietor of a brothel and eventually partners with Mrs. Miller (Christie). Despite the predominance of dark hues (browns, greens), the colors stand out well enough; for a revealing before-and-after test, just compare the DVD transfer to the original film footage shown in the making-of documentary. As for the sound, the Dolby Digital 2.0 audio track contains some unfortunate hiss, yet it nicely serves the omnipresent sound of wind and rain, as well as the atmospheric
Leonard Cohen songs that comprise the soundtrack.
Bonus features include the theatrical trailer plus the previously mentioned documentary and commentary by
Altman and producer
David Foster. Recorded separately, the two commentary tracks don't ever fluidly merge, which is somewhat distracting but also provides some humorous juxtapositions, such as when Foster praises the novel on which the film was based while
Altman derides it as "no great piece of writing." Elsewhere, Foster gushes about
Altman, and
Altman -- big surprise -- complains about producers. However, there are some interesting anecdotes about the filming of the movie that make the commentary worth checking out. What makes this DVD so memorable, though, is the look and feel of this classic from a classic era of American film. ~ Andrew Roe, All Movie Guide