The debate may go on forever as to which is the best Disney film, but there is little question that
Beauty and the Beast would go right to the top of the list. After the outstanding DVD of
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs comes this two-disc set, and for the most part it is an amazing accomplishment. The first disc contains three versions of the film, the theatrical edition, the special edition shown on large-screen theaters, and the work-print, shown at the
1991 New York Film Festival. Each is in 1.85:1 anamorphic video, and they have never looked so good. Colors are vivid in all respects, and motion never shows any breakdown. It really is amazing with so much on the first disc, that it can look as good as it does. Animation has never looked better. The new 5.1 English Dolby Digital track is primarily centered up front with next to no surrounds, which is a shame. A wider expanse of the auditory elements would have taken this film to a new level. Still, it's a small complaint as the track is easy on the ears in all respects.
Along with the movie, this disc contains a commentary track from producer
Don Hahn, directors
Kirk Wise and
Gary Trousdale, and composer
Alan Menken. This is a wonderful track with a wry sense of humor, interesting tidbits on the productions, and a great overall feeling of accomplishment. Finally there is a game that starts on this disc, but continues on the second disc. And that is where the rest of the supplements can be found. The highlight would have to be a 50-minute documentary on all aspects of the production, including story development, production design, the release and awards, the Broadway musical, and much more. Strangely enough , this documentary is repeated again in a different section. This disc includes plenty, with a section called "The Story Behind the Story," in which hosts tell about other Disney films, a "Mrs. Potts Personality Profile Game," music videos for the song "Beauty and the Beast" performed by
Celine Dion and
Peabo Bryson and a pop version by pop singers
Jump5, and much more. While in some ways these extras may not be up to par with some of the best special editions, no doubt there will be little complaint about what has been offered. Disney has done it again, and leaves one anticipating the next in their Platinum Edition series. ~ Trent Fordham, All Movie Guide