Whether you love or dislike the latest installment of the
Star Wars installment, Episode II: Attack of the Clones, there is no question that Fox and Lucasfilm have done an amazing job in translating this title to DVD. As has widely been mentioned, the image, framed at 2.35:1 and anamorphic (there is a separate disc with a cropped pan-and-scan picture), was taken directly from the digital source, the first for a live action movie (other films have been too, but all others were animated, such as
Monsters, Inc.). This direct translation is unquestionably a revelation in how good a picture can look. Colors are impressive in every way, with excellent saturation and fine detail. The darker scenes are solid and show no sign of digital breakdown, something that can harm even the best transfers. The sound, a 5.1 EX Dolby Digital track in English, is also very good, but maybe not quite as aggressive as would be expected. The sound is very clear up front, and there are some uses of the surrounds, but not as often as could have been. Just as with Episode I: The Phantom Menace this is a two disc set, with a commentary on the first disc with
George Lucas, producer
Rick McCallum, editor
Ben Burtt, animation supervisor
Rob Coleman, effects artists
Pablo Helman,
John Knoll, and
Ben Snow.
The second disc contains all the other supplements, and while they are plentiful, they do tend to lack a little substance. Up front are three documentaries, the first, at 56 long minutes, is called "From Puppets to Pixels" and takes an exhaustive look at the creation of digital characters, in particular, Yoda. The second examines the pre-visualization of the film, from early computer setups to the final product. Finally, "Films Are Not Made, They Escape" discusses in length the sound design of the film. Again, with far too many "talking head" interviews, it says a lot but lacks much interest. While extensive, all three of these are, technical and ultimately, boring. As with the Phantom Menace disc, this one contains 12 featurettes of various subjects originally shown on the
Star Wars website. Three additional features on the story line, love story, and action scenes don't amount to much more than fluff pieces. Of greater interest are eight deleted scenes, with optional introductions and a great mockumentary trailer "R2-D2: Beneath the Dome." Finally, along with a "music video" for "Across the Stars" from
John Williams are gallery sections, poster art, a brief visual effects reel, theatrical teasers, and trailer, plus 12 television spots. It's a full plate that looks like it will leave you filled, but in the end is somewhat empty. Still, fans of this film, who are a very devoted bunch, will be pleased. ~ Trent Fordham, All Movie Guide