Andrew V. McLagalen's
Chisum (1970), starring
John Wayne (who also produced), was released on laserdisc in the late 1980's in a decent looking letterboxed edition; but it reappears on DVD with a significantly improved image and also with a couple of major bonus features. The first and most important of the latter is a full-length commentary track by the director,
Andrew V. McLaglen, who goes into myriad aspects of the production, starting from
Andrew J. Fenady's original story, based on years of research into the Lincoln County War that was the background for the story. He's not very specific about the filming of various scenes, such as the shootout by the river, choosing instead to give analysis of the character motivations at such moments. He has fond memories of Wayne, and one wishes that Wayne's estate would get him for a commentary track on
McLintock! -- as it is, he ranges freely across memories of working with Wayne on five major films, and compares the way the actor handled certain kinds of scenes with certain kinds of actors. In the course of describing the production, he attributes a genuine interest in history to his own fascination with the story, while Wayne was more interested in simply making an exciting picture. He goes into the decision behind the casting of almost every major role in the movie, though McLaglen doesn't say enough about
Geoffrey Deuel, who plays perhaps the most important supporting role in the movie, that of William Bonney aka Billy The Kid. On a purely personal note, he doesn't tell much about the relationship between his father and Wayne, but he does vaguely recall some of his early work on Wayne's movies by way of
John Ford, without saying anything about Ford -- and he expresses a genuine distaste for the "New Wave" westerns embodied by
Sam Peckinpah, and remembers crossing paths with Peckinpah in Durango, Mexico when both were shooting down there. And he also relates the somewhat amusing tale of his almost accidental specialization in westerns, which came about because of one movie that he'd done with
James Arness. The movie looks far better here than it did on the laserdisc, with deeper, richer color and a gorgeous image overall. The letterboxing (2.35-to-1) is essential to appreciating this movie, for McLaglen uses almost every corner of the screen, and keeps the action moving forward constantly. The sound is also very sharp and rich, and one wishes that McLaglen had more to say about
Dominic Frontiere's music. The 112 minute movie has been given 30 chapters that are well named and placed, and is supplemented with the featurette "John Wayne And Chisum," and the original trailer. The disc opens automatically to a multi-layered menu that includes selections for English captions and French, Spanish, and Japanese subtitles, and a French audio track. The whole disc production should set a standard for how Wayne's movies ought to be treated, not just by Warner Bros. but every distributor, and one sorely wishes that the company had done this kind of a job on its earlier release of
Stagecoach, a much more important movie. ~ Bruce Eder, All Movie Guide