For what possible reason could this soap opera melodrama of over-privileged teen angst deserve a "Platinum Series" DVD? Love or hate this movie, there's no question that it's a fine DVD all around. The 1.85:1 image, enhanced for widescreen televisions, is natural, full of detail, and exceptionally pleasing to view. Colors are especially well presented -- not overly vivid, but realistic and satisfying. As would be expected, there isn't a distracting element to be found in this theatrical-quality transfer. The 5.1 Dolby Digital track isn't what would be expected from a recent studio film, but that doesn't change the fact that this is a well-rounded soundtrack, simply lacking any significant depth. Adding greatly to this title is a full assortment of supplements, the staple for this particular line from New Line. Hardly revelatory about the filmmaking process, a scene-specific commentary from stars
Mandy Moore,
Alexandra Holden, and director
Clare Kilner is pleasant enough to listen to, as they obviously enjoyed their time working together. Surprisingly, a documentary on the history of young adult literature, from the early 1900s to the present day, is genuinely interesting. Interviews with current writers and the teens that read their works give a better understanding of this particular genre. Three other featurettes, profiles of Moore,
Trent Ford, and Kilner, don't hold up as well. Each is under eight minutes long and comes across as promotional pats on the back. Far more interesting are two deleted scenes, an alternate version of the wedding, and an alternate ending, all with optional commentary. What would a teen film be without music videos? Included here is "Billy S." by generic teen rocker grrrl
Skye Sweetnam and the far more interesting "Why Can't I" by
Liz Phair. Finally, along with the theatrical trailer for this film, are previews for other New Line titles, including
Elf,
Sugar & Spice, and
Love & Basketball. ~ Trent Fordham, All Movie Guide