Rammy M. (m5rammy) from DAYTON, OH wrote on 5/4/2009...
0 of 4 member(s) found this review helpful.
I did Not like this movie.
A number of stories that in the end weave together. Ok, but in the end ... what's the point?
Too much jumping back and forth in time with no explanation. Yes, in the end I did understand it, but again, what's the point? Did they think the story was too weak on its own and needed to be spiced up? eg One character seems to be on his death bed (in a hospital) then he's out, then he's ill and waiting for a transplant. is he getting better? worse? is this before? a relapse? etc.
Another character "has been in and out of jail", suddenly he's in jail, is this a new time? or the last time (where he learned some lesson)? suddenly he's working somewhere else, is this as a prisoner (not exactly chain gang)?
This is not like Memento where there is a clear progression backwards, or like many other movies where there is a definite "then" and "now"
The acting was fine, the camera work was fine (except when it was shaky) etc.
but if you piece it all together chronologically... there is no real conclusion. Maybe the characters worked out their issues, maybe not.
The message seemed to be (if anything) "Sometimes people die, sometimes people want to die" yeah? and? so what!?
Kristina G. (familiagarduno) from COLUMBUS, OH wrote on 1/30/2009...
4 of 5 member(s) found this review helpful.
You must see all three films by this Director/Writer. They include Amorres Perros, Babel and 21 Grams. They are broken up scenes with a built up story that will blow your mind when it all comes together. It's like putting a puzzle together without knowing the finished picture - you're amazed when it works and shocked that it worked. You will love this story as three lives are wound together....