By tracking down the living members of the Weathermen and interspersing new interviews with archival footage,
Sam Green and
Bill Siegel created a documentary that was nominated for an Oscar and which shows how historical events from over 30 years ago can still comment on the current political climate.
The Weather Underground is an even better experience on DVD thanks to the crew at Docu Rama. The film is presented in its original theatrical aspect ratio, and the soundtrack is solid, although obviously it suffers on occasion due to the age and condition of some of the archival materials. The bonus materials on this disc make it one of the best DVD releases of the year. A commentary by director
Sam Green involves discussions in the genesis of this project, the difficulty in tracking down the members of the organization, and the amount of trust they had to build up with many of the people who eventually agreed to be filmed on-camera. Green studiously avoids making any overt political statements, making this an intriguing look at how documentary films are put together. A second commentary track by Weathermen figures
Bill Ayers and
Bernardine Dohrn injects the disc with a pointed political discussion in which they also express feelings of nostalgia, righteous anger, and occasionally dissatisfaction with elements in the finished film. Having their insights adds another fascinating layer to this already-intriguing documentary. A pair of audio communiqués recorded by the group during their years of violent protest, a portion of a documentary featured in the film, and a written statement by the filmmakers all add to this superb disc that should be viewed by anyone with an interest in politics or history. ~ Perry Seibert, All Movie Guide