Joseph H. Lewis'
Gun Crazy (1949) never made it to laserdisc, despite being in sufficient demand theatrically so that its distributor had to keep a 35 mm print available, but it has made it to DVD in very good edition. The movie looks excellent, about a match to the best 35 mm. What makes it special, however, is the lively commentary track by
Glenn Erickson; he jumps all over the place, occasionally to his detriment, but usually to our benefit, bounding between the original short story, the opening section of the movie with its two flashbacks, the cast members, the director's background, and the stylistic characteristics of film noir. He gives an excellent account of the movie's subtext, which evidently slipped right past the Production Code office's censors, and he enjoys delving into the careers of the supporting actors, such as
Berry Kroeger and
Stanley Prager. Erickson's commentary might have used a little editing; once or twice he tries to anticipate a flawed scene or two later on without giving us sufficient warning, which tends to be distracting. Similarly, his attempt to equate the levels of violence and the sensibilities of audiences in 1950 with audiences in the 1990s, and specifically films such as Terminator 2, seems forced. On the other hand, when he uses one scene as a jumping off point for a broader discussion of film noir's cosmic angst, he's dead on target. And Erickson weaves a brilliant account of the tangled writing credits on the movie, though he misses the irony of original story author
MacKinlay Kantor, who was a hardcore right-winger, whereas blacklistee
Dalton Trumbo wrote the screenplay. When Erickson tells us of character actor
Ray Teal's career, he also neglects to mention Teal's longest acting assignment in a string of lawmen, honest or corrupt, on Bonanza, as the sheriff of Virginia City. Still, Erickson's track is always engaging and engrossing, almost as much as the movie, and he is better than many other such commentators. Beyond that, the 87-minute movie has been given an extremely generous and well-placed 25 chapters, and a very clean audio transfer, although the volume is slightly low, but that shortcoming can be compensated for very easily. There is no trailer or other bonus visual material, but the commentary track is so much fun that this DVD would be worth owning even if the movie didn't look half as good as it does. The disc opens automatically on a simple but clever menu that includes options of English, French, and Spanish subtitles. ~ Bruce Eder, All Movie Guide