Abel Gance's
Napoléon (1927), as restored by
Kevin Brownlow and presented by
Francis Ford Coppola, was a major laserdisc release in the mid-'80s from Universal, but has not seen the light-of-day on DVD in America. Universal's Australian division, however, released
Napoléon as a Region 4 disc (playable only in Australia, New Zealand, and related territories, or on properly set up computers, or all-region players) on the occasion of the movie's 75th anniversary in 2002. It's odd what the passage of time and the advance of technology can do to seemingly impressive work out of the past -- at the time of its theatrical re-release in the late '70s, the work done to bring Gance's movie to something approaching full-length had seemed prodigious, in both its quality and results. The results are still okay, but compared to the full-blown restoration job done on
Fritz Lang's
Metropolis, Gance's movie now seems disappointing in many shots, with too much grain, too many little jumps, too little detail, and perhaps too dark as well.
The print as restored and licensed to Universal pushes the sharpness of digital video to the limit, and is found somewhat lacking in the bargain. The tinted sequences come off rather better than the untinted ones, and -- to be sure -- the movie still constitutes great viewing. Gance's shooting and editing, and the performances they present, are astoundingly powerful, and
Carmine Coppola's score has aged extremely well, so that it is easy to get swept up into the movie's action, even 77 years later. Every section of the film has a scene (and sometimes more than one) that grabs the viewer by the throat; it could be something as seemingly unanimated as the shot of Napoléon Bonaparte facing the sea and his lonely quest to keep Corsica French, while a horn plays in the background; or the hero's fight against his rivals as a boy, in the snow; or the rising of the Spanish, Italian, and English-descended Corsicans against the hero; or the hero's flight from Corsica on horseback, to the sea (and into a storm), pursued across the countryside by his rivals; and the intercutting of Napoléon's battle with the storm and the sequences depicting the Reign of Terror's start in France. It's all still some of the finest purely visual storytelling that one is ever likely to see. Gance's use of overlapping shots, montage, and interlocking multiple images was decades ahead of his own time, and much of the movie remains spellbinding despite the now seemingly primitive source materials.
The content is identical to earlier MCA-Universal releases of this title, full-screen (1.33:1) for most of its length but occasionally restoring the original "Polyvision" triptych image (2.55:1), especially in the final section of the movie. This is, of course, the version of
Napoléon released by
Francis Ford Coppola's Zoetrope in the USA. There was a slightly longer restoration prepared by another distributor, containing footage from the film found at a still later date by Brownlow, scored by
Carl Davis, and released in England. That version of
Napoléon has never been released on DVD, and if it ever does become available, might make a fascinating comparison with this edition. The present 226-minute version has been given 19 chapters, which is rather paltry considering the complexity of the movie and its subject. There are no extras of any kind, otherwise, not even a promotional trailer for the re-release. The disc opens to a simple two-layer menu on startup, with the "play" option in the default position. ~ Bruce Eder, All Movie Guide