A must to avoid, the 1977 Hound of the Baskervilles is a misfire all down the line. The concept of having "underground" director
Paul Morrissey bringing an irreverent slant to the original Sherlock Holmes mystery had potential. So did the notion of casting comedians
Peter Cook and
Dudley Moore as Holmes and Watson, with such reliable British performers as
Terry-Thomas,
Joan Greenwood,
Denholm Elliott,
Hugh Griffith,
Spike Milligan and
Roy Kinnear in cameos. But the results are horrendous, despite the fact that producer
Michael White had done a perfectly acceptable combination of spoofery and fidelity to source material in
Monty Python's
Jabberwocky. The one joke that works is the casting of a lovable Irish wolfhound as the "deadly" Baskerville mastiff. What doesn't work in this film could fill a book; one can only refer to the initial mistake of having Holmes and Watson speak in thick provincial accents, which might be good for a single joke but not for an 85-minute feature. For its American release, Hound of the Baskervilles was whittled down to 78 minutes, with several of its scenes out of sequence; no one noticed, no one cared. ~ Hal Erickson, All Movie Guide