Richard Thorpe's
Ivanhoe (1952) is the most beloved of Hollywood's '50s medieval swashbucklers, easily outstripping
Knights of the Round Table (also made by MGM) and Universal's
The Black Shield of Falworth, among other tales of knights in armor. With a cast that embodied the phrase "all star," including
Robert Taylor (convincingly grim but never dull),
Elizabeth Taylor,
Joan Fontaine,
George Sanders,
Finlay Currie, and
Emlyn Williams, superb supporting players including
Robert Douglas,
Felix Aylmer,
Norman Wooland, and
Guy Rolfe, and the biggest budget for any costume epic (apart from
Gone With the Wind) in a quarter century, the movie represented perhaps the peak of the postwar Hollywood studio system's ability to generate spectacle; it's helped by a great story and a better script, into which this cast fit perfectly. The DVD doesn't give the movie as grand a treatment as one would have hoped or expected -- this film begs for a commentary track, and there is none. At the least,
Ivanhoe invites a documentary about its making, and that's also absent. What there is, however, is one of the most beautiful Technicolor transfers seen on DVD up to this date.
The laserdisc of
Ivanhoe, released in the late '80s, looked very good, but this DVD runs circles around it for detail -- the skin textures are visible even in the medium shots, and the first time we see
George Sanders in close-up in chain-mail, every tiny link can be seen in high-relief. In contrast to pre-World War II Technicolor, the images look realistic, which is as it should be in this movie, which has more of a veneer of realism in its script than almost any other movie of its kind; a couple of shots of
Elizabeth Taylor fall slightly short, but those few seconds don't mar the overall experience of watching this disc. The audio levels, including
Miklos Rozsa's score, have been set at a healthy level, and the 107-minute feature has been given a generous 27 chapters. There are original trailers for this and two other movies,
Scaramouche and
Knights of the Round Table -- the
Ivanhoe trailer looks as good as the old laserdisc and better than old TV prints of this picture did; the
Knights of the Round Table trailer is, like the movie itself, in CinemaScope and is rather peculiar in that it has no scenes from the movie for its first minute but rather an extended crawl over medieval emblems. As an added bonus feature, the producers have included the 1952 Oscar-winning
Tom & Jerry cartoon "The Two Mouseketeers" (which is in even better shape than the main feature). English and French dialogue tracks are also available, as are subtitles in English, French, and Spanish. The disc opens to an easy-to-use multi-layer menu, offering simple access to all of these features. ~ Bruce Eder, All Movie Guide