The first hour of the Roan Group's DVD of
The Outlaw looks extraordinary, especially in light of some of the wretched looking versions of this public domain movie that are in circulation, and the last hour looks good -- but in between are about 11 minutes of not-very-clear night material that is about average for this badly abused film. It's only another chapter in the picture's star-crossed history.
The Outlaw was one of the most notorious movies of its era, a Western intended to scandalize and entice audiences. Made by independent producer Howard Hughes, it was rejected and revamped for years by the censors, so much so that it became a running joke in Hollywood.
The Outlaw appeared at various times in editions running 103 and 95 minutes, but the Roan Group DVD is the first presentation of Hughes's uncut 117-minute version, which was never widely distributed. Much of this DVD looks as good as the digital discs of some of the greatest Westerns of the same period,
Stagecoach and
Red River, and may have better audio mastering than the latter. The irony is that even the trailers for
Red River and
Stagecoach are worth more cinematically than
The Outlaw is as a movie; as a cowboy picture, it's at least a decade out of date in its handling of story and action. Cinematographer
Gregg Toland does his job amazingly well, with some gloriously beautiful shots, but the direction by Hughes (and an uncredited
Howard Hawks) often resembles that of a bad silent Western, while other parts are just plain amateurish, and the extended finale is interminable. Billy the Kid (Buetel) and Doc Holliday (
John Huston) meet in Lincoln County, NM, where Pat Garrett (
Thomas Mitchell) is sheriff, and contend with each other for a horse and then for a woman (
Jane Russell). Apart from Huston's and
Mitchell's presence in the cast, and the fact that
Howard Hawks was fired off the picture, the movie could be ignored, but for the presence of
Russell. From her first appearance 21 minutes in, the movie is groundbreaking in its treatment of her character (and physique). The prominence given her bosom in practically every shot she's in, and her character's raw sexuality, were unique in their time, and the production of this movie heralded the making of the higher profile, lust-drenched Western
Duel in the Sun which, with
The Outlaw, forever altered the role of the libido in cowboy movies. The Roan DVD is divided into 24 chapters, most of them useful and easy to navigate (although the last chapter, covering the impossibly talkie finale, is almost useless), but copies of this disc also had trouble making the dual-layer transition in some machines. The RKO trailer, dating from years after the initial 1943 attempt at a release, is included as a bonus. ~ Bruce Eder, All Movie Guide