Fans of this legendary cult classic will be more than satisfied with The Criterion Collection's two-disc DVD release of
Carnival of Souls. The first disc contains the original (shorter) theatrical release of the chilling B-movie cheapie, close to an hour of eerie outtakes, a charming 1989 public television documentary on the film's history, and much more. The second disc houses the slightly longer director's cut that was seen in theaters in 1989, an hour of
additional outtakes, and many other extras that fanatics will happily devour and casual viewers will ignore. While
Carnival of Souls remains an exceptionally well-made chiller (think of a feature-length episode of the Twilight Zone shot like a shoestring
8 1/2), this DVD shows that the story behind the film is just as interesting.
Carnival of Souls was the only feature that producer/director
Herk Harvey and writer
John Clifford were ever able to squeeze in between their steady flow of industrial films. These two saw little of the films' profits and their fellow Kansans hated their quirky art house horror flick. The movie was very influential for George Romero, a fellow industrial filmmaker who struck gold with the terrifying
Night of the Living Dead. Romero was able to leave industrial films for a long career in features, but
Harvey and Clifford stayed in Kansas. Even leading lady
Candace Hilligoss and the movie's other actors went on to other things. Decades later
Carnival of Souls is rediscovered and the talent behind it is feted around the world. Watching these filmmakers and actors finally get the praise and attention they always deserved is gratifying and moving. Another fine DVD package from The Criterion Collection. ~ Nick Dedina, All Movie Guide