Jason C. (JJC) from NEWARK, NJ wrote on 12/14/2007...
Remakes, yet again.
Out of nowhere, Warner Brothers decided to tackle the early seventies disaster genre. With "The Towering Inferno," "Earthquake" and like four "Airport" flicks to choose from, the WB decided to grab a good director (Wolfgang Petersen) and an ensemble of character actors and dish out an updated version of "The Poseidon Adventure," now shortend to simply "Poseidon."
This time round, Gene Hackman's character of the original is split into two characters, neither of which is a faith-questioned priest. Here we have the always awesome Kurt Russell tackling the role of Robert Ramsey, an aging ex-firemen who was also the ex-mayor of New York City, and Josh Lucas playing Dylan Johns, a suave card-shark, who makes a living hustling. So, the basic plot is simple: a gigantic tidal wave hits an oceanliner, which overturns. Thousands of deaths and only a handful survive...and it is their story we witness, trying to escape with their lives before the boat eventually sinks.
Now let me tell you why, this remake works.
In due respect to the original, which is a classic, it is dated and a tad bit hokey (however Hackman's performance still stands out in that film, and is not matched here). Written by Mark Protosevich, who hasn't had a script produced since his first entry "The Cell," does a very good job telling this story in what is practically real time. The performances are handled well, especially from the two leads (Russell and Lucas), however there is some cheese dialogue that bleeds through, I mean after all, it is a Hollywood popcorn flick. In addition to Russell and Lucas, the survival hungry team consists of: a single mother (Jacinda Barrett) and her young son (Jimmy Bennett), Ramsey's daughter (Emmy Rossum) and her disapproved of boyfriend (Mike Vogel), a suicidal gay man (Richard Dreyfuss), and a beautiful stowaway (MÃa Maestro). The sets are great, and the film is tight. The claustrophobic feel and surprisingly shocking death scenes add to cool factor of the film.
I can't say if this is better than its predecessor or not (they are equal in my opinion), but it's an easy and tight 98 minutes, and escapist entertainment that works.