Only for the die-hard or new-fan...
Templar | Seattle, WA | 11/30/2004
(3 out of 5 stars)
"and not much for the in-betweeners.
This is actually a fairly decent episode. An un-aired (as of yet) retelling of the classic Eastman and Laird "Michelangelo #1 micro-series"... i'm quite pleased to see Klunk (the cat) finally make his way into the new cartoon show. With the exception of the goofy "everyone's invited over for a feast" thing, this episode stays amazingly true to the comic... although, i doubt i'll ever take Silver Sentry seriously again, should he appear in later episodes. This episode is quite holiday-focused (as you probably gleaned from the title. heh)... and without prior awareness of the Mirage comics, you may think it's just another marketing ploy. And well... it sorta is clearly the timing is no mistake, nor is it's release directly to DVD in late October...
still though, it's the last of the "micro-series" comics to be recreated in the new cartoon, and i doubt i'm alone when i say that i was chewing at the bit, for this episode to finally see the light of day.
The down side, is that if you purchase this DVD, you're getting three other previously released episodes. that's... that's pretty lame right there. this is their idea of "special features" apparently, to give us nothing... and then buy us off with a few episodes we probably already have.
that being said however, i'm sure a bunch of you are like me, and gleefully plunked down another $15 - $20 bucks or so, just for a sense of completion (not to mention an episode none of us had seen yet). *sigh*... yeah, we're collectors... need i really say more?
Or, alternatively, if this is your first TMNT dvd, or it's for a kid'o with a green streak... i highly recommend it, as the three other episodes are actually fairly important plot-centric moments from the first season of the show. A good jumping on point, and a great way to introduce a whole new generation to the crack... er... hobby... no wait, um... innocent cartoon show, that no one would EVER obsess over and spend disgusting amounts of cash procuring anything with the logo... yeah... uh... let's just forget that last little bit and move on.
In short, and for those of you skimming:
-If you're an obsessive fan, you'll get it... you have no choice.
-If you're a new fan, or just want to present someone with a gift, i believe it would make an excellent choice.
-If you're in the middle there... not obsessed, but not largely unfamiliar, i don't think a single 24+ minute episode is worth the money you'll spend on it... i'm sure it'll air on Television soon.
"
Very good X-mas ep!
Templar | 12/18/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I love the new TMNT cartoon, it's the best! So when I heard that the animation company was going to spoil us and release the x-mas ep on dvd early, I was very happy! I got a few days after its release, and being the impatient little brat that I am, couldn't resist watching it right away.
I loved it! Beautiful animation, Mikey centered, and just overall good! After many fangirl squeals of joy, most likely making my parents think I'm nuts, I watched it again!
Then I decided (considering I'm 18 and should have SOME form of willpower by now) to wait until Thanksgivings weekend before popping in that dvd in again. It was worth the wait!
What I'm saying is, I loved it!
While the other reviewer before me complained about the bonus eps, I was happy about them. I had been concerned that they were going to throw season 3 eps on it and mess up the ep order even more than they already have (Darn Funimations!). I was glad to see that it was just some eps from season one, including the first epsiode! This is good because the first dvd volume glitched on the first ep, very annoying, so now I have a dvd copy of that episode without any mess ups! ^-^
If you're a fan of the new toon, you should get this!"