Search - Verdi - Aida / Norma Fantini, Marco Berti, Ildiko Komlosi, Mark Doss, Orlin Anastassov, Kazushi Ono, Brussels Opera on DVD

Robert Wilson's Aida of the Unliving

J Scott Morrison | Middlebury VT, USA | 08/08/2006

(2 out of 5 stars)

"Want a zombie production of 'Aida'? You've come to the right place. This highly stylized -- what else?, this is Robert Wilson -- production from Brussels' Theatre de la Monnaie was controversial at its premiere in 2004, and if this DVD of a live performance is any indication, the Belgian audience was vastly unimpressed. I recall that the production was booed by the audience when it was taken to Covent Garden. And with good reason. This is one of the most boring opera productions I've ever seen. The staging is characterized by stylized movements by the singers presumably based on poses seen in ancient Egyptian friezes and pottery. The ugly costumes are stylized Egyptian, I suppose, but look more like something to be seen on puppets. The result is that these aren't living people but ghostly avatars who certainly are not capable of the very real emotions of Verdi's characters. The result, then, is that this production is dead on arrival. No one makes eye contact with anyone else; even when Amneris commands Aida to 'look into my eyes' she turns her back on her, making the imperative impossible. Psychology? No, just plain dumb stylization that doesn't convey anything. The lengthy booklet notes attempt to assign psychological import to aspects of the production but are a good example of the philosophical sludge and special pleading of too much French writing on the arts.

Musically the production isn't half bad, although there are better ones out there -- a recent one from the Teatre Liceu in Barcelona sings rings around this Monnaie production -- but it isn't worth spending your pennies for. The best singer is probably the Hungarian mezzo Ildiko Komlosi as Amneris, but her low notes do sometimes disappear into her chest. Norma Fantini's Aida is generally effective but is occasionally shrieky. Marco Berti, as Radamès, has a beefy but unappealing tenor. Mark Doss's Amonasro is pretty good, but it's a long wait until he finally gets on in Act III! The best singers are the bassos -- Orlin Anastassov as Ramfis and Guido Jentjens as the King. The choreography is awful; one notes that the choreographer is not named; could it be at his/her request? And what's with the male dancers doing the 'Sacred Dance of the Priestesses' in Act I? The orchestra of the Monnaie plays well, and young Japanese conductor Kazushi Ono leads a rather swift and light reading of the score.

Unless you're a diehard Robert Wilson fan -- and I know he has his cult following -- I'd suggest you think carefully before you plunk down your money for this one.

Scott Morrison"

Musically and visually stunning performance

C. Harbison | Montague, MA United States | 11/15/2006

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Certainly this is not a production of the old warhorse Aida that traditional opera fans will naturally gravitate to. And I am not a Robert Wilson groupie--this is my first experience of his direction. But it is a revelation--a highly stylized Egyptian melodrama about the relation of the material and metaphysical worlds (as the interesting but obscure essay in the DVD booklet suggests). The singers do not look at each other, but their faces are very expressive, and gestures and movements are abstract and based on ancient Egyptian paintings and reliefs. Wilson's use of what may seem an obvious gestural device never looks merely derivative or kitschy--always earnest and (perhaps too) well thought out (even down to the painted finger nails which give the hands a slightly unnatural length as with the Egyptian originals). The shifting lighting and colors are at times ethereal and at others dark and earthy, even oppressive. The singing is very good, not great, as with several other DVDS (Verona, etc.) and rises to several impressive climaxes, as well as a transcendent ending; the conducting is often revelatory in its angular rhythms and sharp details (well matched to the production's conceit overall). Wilson has created a highly original, and moving, interpretation of an opera that might otherwise seem totally bound to a specific time and place. For anyone who loves this great work, I would highly recommend viewing this powerful performance."

Absolute massacre of a beloved work of art. Boring to the h

Kersi Von Zerububbel | San Diego, CA USA | 07/25/2008

(2 out of 5 stars)

"I have seen quite a few productions of Aida and I am not a opera officionado. So speaking as a layman who loves watching opera this is without doubt the worst production of Aida that I have ever seen. I was at first intrigued because the DVD packet said that it was a "Zen like" production. Well guess what? I don't think Zen and grand opera mix well. There is minimal acting which I expected after reading about the Zen stuff but bad acting is something else. The sets, costumes, and in general the whole production was a crashing bore.

I will stick to the Met's production (Levine,Domingo, Millo etc) thank you!"