Documentary filmmaker Mark Moskowitz turns literary sleuth in this marvelous tale of a vanished novelist. Enchanted by the 1972 novel The Stones of Summer, Moskowitz was surprised to discover no subsequent trace of the aut... more »hor, Dow Mossman. This led him on a roundabout search for the man, including nicely freewheeling detours to talk about writing with critic Leslie Fiedler and editor Robert Gottlieb, among many distinguished others. Although Moskowitz's detective format is somewhat labored, the true story of Mossman's retreat from writing is fascinating, and the joy of books (and talking about books) is always front and center. The suspense of Moskowitz's quest becomes real, and Stone Reader contains moments that would be implausible if they were in a fiction film--except, of course, they aren't made up. Bibliophiles of every stripe need to see this movie; and if you're not a book lover already, it may make you one. --Robert Horton« less
Actors:Carl Brandt, Frank Conroy (III), Bruce Dobler, Robert C.S. Downs, Robert Ellis (VIII) Genres:Drama Sub-Genres:Drama Studio:New Yorker Video Format:DVD - Color,Anamorphic - Closed-captioned DVD Release Date: 02/17/2004 Release Year: 2004 Run Time: 2hr 7min Screens: Color,Anamorphic Number of Discs: 2 SwapaDVD Credits: 2 Total Copies: 0 Members Wishing: 0 Edition: Special Edition MPAA Rating: PG-13 (Parental Guidance Suggested) Languages:English See Also:
"This movie is a very, very long three hours. I disliked it not in a scolding way but because it induced boredom to the level of panic, a desire to flee the theater."
Odious
M. Fine | 02/17/2004
(1 out of 5 stars)
"Couldn't believe so many critics (but not all) were taken in by this. More a mockumentary than anything else, since the film purports to document real events, but in fact sets up ridiculous shots of, for example, Moskowitz and friends going to their mailboxes to retrieve copies of the book. And then, of course, the fake "search" for Mossman - a lovely, troubled man who seems to have had, despite everything, a real, lifelong engagement with literature - who, it seems, could probably have been found in 10 minutes, rather than months. The literary critics and writers interviewed are all interesting, but by the end it wouldn't have surprised me if the filmmaker had asked, " What would you say if I told you I had Dow Mossman in the trunk of my car?""
From 2/14/04 NY Times on Scamming the System:
Idoru69 | NY United States | 02/17/2004
(1 out of 5 stars)
"As the Amazon sites expand their visitors are seen as an increasingly important. Mark Moskowitz, an independent filmmaker, sent an e-mail message to about 3,000 people this week asking them to review the DVD of his film "Stone Reader," which goes on sale soon. "If you didn't see it but heard it was good, go ahead and post anyway, (what the heck)," Mr. Moskowitz told them. "It doesn't obligate you for anything, even the truth." Not even the truth? I beg to differ. . ."
Unworthy?
Stephen Elderbrock | 02/15/2004
(2 out of 5 stars)
"I happen not to be one of the 3,000 people who received an email from the director asking them to review the film in a positive way even if they have not seen it (according to an article in the New York Times and News.com).
Therefore I can possibly give a more independent review.
Unfortunately there are not many good things to say about this film. The plot is not well carried out, the characters are somewhat linear, there is a lack of proper balance in the way the story is told. There are many better things out there. For them 3,000 emails may not be necessary."
Film Is Called "Stone READER" For a Reason
Stephen Elderbrock | Ottawa, Ohio | 02/23/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I found this film fascinating - I had never read "The Stones of Summer" before, nor even heard of it, or the movie. But anyone who complains that the film focusses too much on the filmmaker hasn't noticed the title of the film -- "Stone READER" -- it is a film about the journey of the young boy who first read Mossman's book and is now searching for him. It is not a film about Mossman or even so much about writers - it is a film about readers of books, and especially this one reader. The movie explores many themes, including the quest to find out more about an author you love and why some books and authors catch on and others do not. The very aspects of the film that others seem to find annoying, I found fascinating -- as we watch this filmmaker search and head down blind alleys, and yet keep searching. If you enjoy a good quest, if you have ever wanted to write to or go visit a favorite author, or if you just like a good story, I would highly recommend this film."