A TRAIN WRECKS & SHE WAKES UP IN THE HOSPTIAL TO FIND OUT THAT IT'S BEEN ASSUMED THAT SHE'S PATRICIA. HUGH'S MOTHER TAKES HER IN AND SHE FALLS IN LOVE WITH HUGH'S BROTHER BILL. JUST WHEN SHE THINKS EVERYTHING IS GOING HER ... more »WAY, HER EX-BOYFRIEND SHOWS UP.« less
Kindra K. (Onion) from SAN ANTONIO, TX Reviewed on 9/25/2011...
Wonderful romantic movie!
1 of 1 member(s) found this review helpful.
Brittany D. from NAMPA, ID Reviewed on 10/3/2010...
****may contain spoilers****
-just watched this a few nights ago on netflix and i loved it. it's def. a chick flick, as you hopefully already know and have already clicked on a link to another movie for a different kind of movie if chick flicks aren't your 'thing'. in this movie, 1.)the plot was good, 2.)great chemistry amongst actor(es)s' 3.)LOTS of HUMOR!. shirly maclaine really takes the cake, and brendan fraser's acting was actually pretty good ( considering i usually can't stand him in films he's in) rikki lake plays the confused mother superbly and the romance is old fashioned, the director wasn't trying to find a new way for the main male and female lead to fall in love with each other(like in leap year- yuck. it's more like letters to juliet, only no fiance at the other end) this movie was far from a disappointment... i hope to own it soon :D
**** may contain spoilers****
2 of 2 member(s) found this review helpful.
Rebecca S. (redrose) from MARIPOSA, CA Reviewed on 4/9/2010...
It's a Cinderella story for the 90's with Shirley MacLaine playing the unpredictable fairy godmother at the center of this comic Cinderella story.
3 of 3 member(s) found this review helpful.
Adrienne B. Reviewed on 8/12/2009...
1 of 5 member(s) found this review helpful.
Great romantic flick!
Joan Monica Wanat | Wheeling, IL USA | 07/29/2002
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Connie, broke and pregnant, accidently ends up on a train heading toward Boston without a ticket. When a stranger, Hugh Winterbourne, helps her out by pretending that his wife's ticket is Connie's, and then takes her to join him and his wife in their cabin, the chaos begins. After the train crashes and Hugh and his wife die, Connie is mistaken for Hugh's pregnant wife. Since the Winterbourne's had not yet met Hugh's wife, Connie finds herself pretending to be Hugh's widow so she can care for her child, but feels guilt ridden over her deception-- especially when she falls in love with Hugh's brother, Bill, and the rest of the Winterbourne family. And who's sending her notes asking who she "really" is?On its own, this movie is a great romantic comedy-- showing how one instance can drag a person into a situation he or she never intended. Lake, Fraser, McClaine, and the actor who plays "Paco" do a fabulous job at making the viewer fall in love with all the characters. I have watched this movie many times, and intend to watch it many more.This story is based on "I Married a Deadman" by Cornell Woolrich, which is a much darker story than the movie. I'm glad they changed the title when they made this into a movie because there are many differences between the original story and the movie; therefore, no one who read the book will mistakenly watch the movie and expect a faithful adaptation. While both are good, they should be taken indenpendantly of each other."
qleaper | 01/07/2000
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I want to be adopted by Shirley MacLaine and her butler Paco. Based on a case of mistaken identity following a train wreck; a young, homeless woman has a baby and is taken in by a wealthy family who believe her to be their daughter-in-law. She meets her putative brother-in-law, who suspects she is not who she claims to be and they fall in love. Although he discovers her real identity, he pretends to believe her story in an effort to be sure that she doesn't leave. The movie is fun to watch, very romantic...there is a tango scene which Brendan Fraser fans run over and over again. He plays a snobbish, bright and ironic young man who has ended up holding the bag as the responsible member of his rich family. Shirley MacLaine is brilliant as the mother, and Ricki Lake does a reasonably good job as a Cinderella candidate. The film could have benefited from a few extra scenes to clarify Bill's attraction to Patricia, but is a fun romance/comedy with a happy ending."
A Nice Surprise
qleaper | Southern California | 04/05/1999
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Being a movie buff, I was surprised I had never seen this movie or heard much of it when it was shown on a bus from Massachusetts to New York. Since I knew nothing about it, I had very low expectations (my guess is it didn't do too well at the box office), and was surprised to see the wonderful Shirley MacLaine and the consistently good Brendan Fraser. On the other hand, I did not recognize Ricki Lake at all, even though I have seen some J. Waters movie she was in. I had to wait until the credits to find out who it was. Brendan Fraser has turned out to be one of the best actors of his generation, if not for his choice of movies. Hopefully Gods and Monsters will open some doors for more serious roles. However, he shows a very good comedic timing in Mrs. Winterbourne, and did very well against Ms. MacLaine. Overall this is a very funny and entertaining movie."
WHERE'S THE DVD?!?!?!?!?
R. Brasher | Cordova, TN | 04/27/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is one of my all-time favorite movies. Shirley MacLaine rules as the non-traditional matron. Ricki Lake does a fine job and Brendan Frasier is outstanding. Yes, more time could have been given to developing the relationship between Connie and Bill, but there's enough to get the point. Paco is AWESOME! His humorous drunken-binge scene makes it all worthwile.The "powers that be" need to get off their butts and get this on DVD. Don't understand why it's not when I see all the crap they've already migrated!I WANT MY DVD..."
Good Movie but Not So Good DVD!
R. Brasher | 08/23/2005
(3 out of 5 stars)
"I really wish I had read the reviews before I bought this DVD and saw the warning that the new DVD is pan and scan only and that the old DVD which had both widescreen and pan and scan is out of print but when I saw this DVD for Mrs. Winterbourne in a store at a low price of about 6 dollars I bought it thinking that was a bargain and that I was getting one of my favorite romantic comedies in widescreen but when I went to watch the DVD I was disappointed to find out that it was just an edited pan and scan version and there was no widescreen version especially as I had gotten rid of my pan and scan video version in order to update to the widescreen DVD so my question is Why in the world would anyone put out what they call a remastered edition on DVD and than release it in pan and scan and not widescreen? isn't that taking a step backwards? I like this movie and I think Shirley McClaine, Ricki Lake and Brendan Fraiser are all very good and I liked the opposites attract love story between the good looking guy and the average looking girl and I would rate the movie 4 stars but the pan and scan only DVD gets 1 star and I'm stuck with this DVD because the place I bought it from will not take back DVD's that have been opened so my only option is to sell or trade this DVD at a store that sells, buys and trades used DVDs and hope I can find a used copy of the old DVD that included both widescreen and pan and scan! BTW: I wish Ricki Lake would go back to making movies or get into a TV sitcom or something, she was really good when she had her recurring roll as the sister in The King of Queens."