Search - Mystery!: Inspector Lewis on DVD

K. K. (GAMER)
Reviewed on 4/6/2024...

Slow burn public television that stalls at times. Some people enjoy this style while others fall asleep!

Excellent sequel! More, please!

Price Grisham | Essex, MA United States | 08/11/2006

(5 out of 5 stars)

"I watched this episode eagerly, yet somewhat appreshensively--but was delighted with the way Lewis had gained in his professional insights, while retaining his personality from the earlier Morse series. Morse having been the academic foil from whom Lewis learned (and who learned from Lewis), the introduction of a young academic as Lewis' suborindate was a brilliant stroke---as well as that of giving the younger man a theological background, even as Lewis struggles with his own loss of faith. (Indeed, a point of fine-tuned accuracy: the assistant is from Cambridge University, Oxford's rival and historically somewhat more sympathetic to traditional Christian theology).

I must agree with the reviewer who thought this episode rather more rushed than those that starred John Thaw. A few things did seem thrown in at the last moment. But how wonderful to see all the old Oxford sites, including (I believe) the Trout Inn at the end of the episode. Having once applied for doctoral studies there (Oxford, not the Trout, though I'm sure the two would become intertwined), I must confess that it was fantasatic to see the "city of dreaming spires" again! I sincerely hope there are many more episodes to come! (I would gladly volunteer as an "extra" on the set if they need a pseudo-academic with mild cerebral palsy!)"

An Old Formula in a New Mystery. Inspector Lewis Retains His

mirasreviews | McLean, VA USA | 08/01/2006

(4 out of 5 stars)

""Inspector Lewis" is the successor to the immensely popular "Inspector Morse" detective series that featured the reclusive, erudite, Oxford Detective Chief Inspector Morse, created by novelist Colin Dexter, and his younger working-class partner Detective Sergeant Lewis. "Inspector Morse" began in 1987 and ran 33 episodes until Morse's death in 2000. "Inspector Lewis" picks up when DI Lewis returns from a 2-year assignment in the Virgin Islands. A lot has happened in the 5 years since Morse's death. Three years ago, Lewis lost his wife to an unsolved hit-and-run accident. This left him bitter and apparently unsuitable for duties in Oxford, so Lewis was transferred to the Virgin Islands. Now his new, temporary partner Detective Sergeant James Hathaway asks, "Has Oxford changed much since you've been away?" Lewis replies, "Nope. It changed before I left."

Regan Peverill (Sophie Winkleman), a mathematics student at Oxford University, is shot to death while volunteering at a Sleep Laboratory. Her classmate Daniel Griffon (Charlie Cox) apparently entered the building with his unique key code just before the shooting and has lost a gun from his dorm room, making Danny the prime suspect. DCS Innocent (Rebecca Frost) reluctantly allows DI Lewis (Kevin Whately) to head the investigation until he can be replaced. Although the DCS discourages "speculating unnecessarily", Lewis and DS Hathaway (Laurence Fox) doubt that the case is as cut and dried as it seems. Danny's family owns the luxury auto company Griffin Motors, and he is set to inherit controlling interest when he turns 21. Since his father's death. the company has been under the control of Danny's uncle Rex Griffon (Jack Ellis), mother Trudie (Jemma Redgrave), and finance director Tom Pollock (Danny Webb). Danny is an unstable young man obsessed with the idea that his uncle murdered his father. Professor Denniston (Michael Maloney) was tutoring Danny the night of the murder and provides his alibi. But more murders are in store. And Professor Denniston's clock is wrong.

"Inspector Lewis" tries to recapture the formula that was part of "Inspector Morse"'s great success, and it does a pretty good job. Lewis is still the ordinary guy. His younger partner Hathaway is a more educated former seminary student who was booted out of school for reasons unknown. The interplay between them recalls the relationship of Morse and Lewis: An Everyman and an Oxbridge-educated detective with very different, complimentary perspectives. Now Lewis is the world-weary partner, and he's atheistic, in contrast to Hathaway's religious background. So Lewis has taken on the Morse role in some respects and retained his old working-class identity in others. The recipe might sound stale and contrived, but Lewis is still a likeable character and Hathaway is sharp and intriguing. "Inspector Lewis" has a characteristic Greek Tragedy bent: Old family secrets and contemporary character flaws combine with tragic consequences. This Lewis mystery comes off as well as the later Morse mysteries."

Dreaming Spires of the Past

Matthew Gladney | Champaign-Urbana, IL USA | 08/04/2006

(4 out of 5 stars)

"From 1987-2000, mystery lovers across the world immersed themselves in the television adventures of Inspector Endeavour Morse and his sidekick, Sgt. Robbie Lewis. They solved intricate crimes, all the while taking-in the beautiful scenery of the city of Oxford and the surrounding countryside. Then, Colin Dexter, the author of the Morse novels that the series was based on, decided to kill-off his signature character, and the television series followed suit. Even more sad was the passing of John Thaw, the talented actor who portrayed Inspector Morse, just two years after the series ended.

Enter Kevin Whately in 2005. Whately played Sgt. Lewis alongside Thaw's Morse for the entire series (minus one episode), and has returned to the colleges and dreaming spires of Oxford once more in a show of his own, aptly titled "Inspector Lewis." It's five years since Morse's death, and much has changed in Lewis's life. His wife passed away in a car accident, he lost his faith, saw his kids grow up and move out, and has just returned from an assignment abroad. When his new partner asks if Oxford has changed much during his absence, Lewis wearily replies, "It changed before I left."

There is a new superintendent running the Oxford police, and she does not take to Lewis immediately. Morse's old sidekick is given a new assistant in the form of DS Hathaway, a younger man who used to attend divinity school. He is keenly intelligent, has a quiet strength, and is played well by actor Laurence Fox. Lewis and Hathaway are assigned to investigate the murder of student Regan Peverill, shot while she was a patient at a sleep clinic. The suspects range from a disturbed male student who may or may not have been sleeping with the deceased, the father of the disturbed student, an egotistical professor, the manager of the sleep clinic, and a plethora of other suspicious characters.

"Inspector Lewis" retains many of the traditional elements of the preceding "Inspector Morse" series, and references the character of Morse quite a bit. There are references to Hamlet, the city of Oxford is featured prominently, and fans of the old show will appreciate the inclusion of Clare Holman as Dr. Laura Hobson. The unraveling of the crime is, I suppose, satisfactory, although the pacing of the story felt faster than a typical Morse story of old. If you're not familiar with the character of Robbie Lewis, then this is a great place to start. He stands on his own quite well. There is, however, a pervasive sense of sadness that encompasses "Inspector Lewis," as the past makes way for the future.

-- Matthew Gladney"