Olaf the Bear | 07/28/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I think this is the best south park DVD out of all of them. It has Cartmans mom is a dirty slut, Cartmans mom is still a dirty slut (where you find out who the dad is), chickenlover, and my favorite ike's wee-wee (drugs are bad ummmk) Buy this video it is sweeeeeeeet!"
More than Advertised
Robbway | Forest Hill, MD USA | 01/07/2000
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Although not the best South Park Volume, it is consistently funny with the rest of the series. The most important feature is the inclusion of the TERRANCE AND PHILLIP episode as a bonus track. It is not listed on the box anywhere.In addition to the episodes, I found the Trey & Matt introductions to be oddly amusing and downright disturbing.Well presented as always, clear as a bell, and most importantly, no Comedy Central Logo in the corner. Still, hats off to Comedy Central for holding onto this show."
Great For A Best Of.
Robbway | 08/26/2003
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Now that the complete seasons of South Park are coming out, I have no need to buy these best-ofs, but if you are strapped for cash and really love South Park, these sets are great because they're presented in chronological order, unlike the Friends best-ofs. Also, they're quite cheap, so you probably won't lose a big amount of money. Best-of-Volume 4 is the best. It has the most constistently hilarious episodes, the last of the first season and the first four of the second season. 'Terrance and Phillip in Not Without My Anus' is features here, too, though it's not advertised on the cover. Great little bonus, especially since this episode rarely makes it to TV. The episodes featured in this best of are:Cartman's Mom is a Dirty Slut: This is the gut-bustingly funny season finale for season one. Cartman is on a mission to find his father, and it's no easy task, because his mom is what we reffer to as 'bear who can't keep legs together.' This episode ends on a cliffhanger that made lots of people angry. Cartman's Mom is Still a Dirty Slut: This episode was the second of the second season. It aired after 'Terrance and Phillip in Not Without My Anus,' but it comes right after the first Cartman's Mom episode. It is pretty funny, but weaker in comparision to the other episodes on this set. Terrance and Phillip in Not Without My Anus: This is one of the most brilliant things to ever go to television. It makes absoloutly no sense. Things happen that have no importance to the plot ('I'm going to put on a pirate costume!') and tons of fart jokes. Nobody liked it when it aired, but that's OK, 'cause now we all know what a masterpiece it is. Don't miss this. It's the best of the set. Chickenlover: Someone is violating chickens. It's up to Barbrady to learn to read so that he can figure out the clues that the Chickenlover has left at his crime scenes. This episode is very funny and a favorite of many fans. And ALWAYS remember to RESPECT MY AUTHORITY! Ike's Wee Wee: My second favorite of this set, this epsisode features the kids misunderstanding the meaning of circumcisn or however the heck you spell that. Mr. Mackey also becomes a drug addict in the funniest moments of this episode. The DVD quality of this is great. I don't understand people complaining about the picture quality and sound. They both were fine, especially the picture. There weren't any special features on the DVDs, but there are the usual hilarious introductions my Trey and Matt. These ones aren't quite up to the high-standards of their 'Fireside Chats,' but they're still funny. The Terrance and Phillip episode features them in a parking lot chat and the rest have them as entertainers at a retirement home. I am very sad that more introductions won't show up on the season DVD sets. Overall, this is a fine DVD, but if you have money to spend, the complete season are even better!'Later"
The Best of the Best South Park Volume
Avery | Kirkland, WA | 05/31/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I had to do some shopping around before I discovered this Volume. This is the best one. Cartman is the highlight of two of the episodes with [the episode about Cartman's Mom] and [the second episode about Cartman's Mom]. This one has him doing the T-party gag, the "Westside Homey" gag, and the "Come Sail Away" Gag. Funny Stuff. Then there is the Chicken .. episode. This has Cartman doing the "Respect My Authataw!!" gag. Funny Funny stuff. This is the funniest one of them all and they also put the Terance and Phillip 30 minute cartoon "Not Without My Anus" cartoon that is not listed on the package. I sorted through all 6 Volumes and this stood out the most. This is the only DVD of South Park I have, but I have seen all the episodes to know this is the one for the buck!!!Now, if only they will release the episodes where Cartman tries to get 10 million dollars (Tooth Ferry, Boy Band, Religious Cult, etc). Those were the funniest to date."