Search - Carlos Kleiber - Beethoven Symphonies 4 and 7 on DVD

... Hear and Watch the Music Take Shape

Haroot Avanesian | La Crescenta, CA United States | 04/02/2005

(5 out of 5 stars)

"I had the luck to see and record this concert being broadcast on PBS many years ago. For years I searched and hoped to find the DVD of this magnificent concert and my wish has finally been fulfilled. Oscar Levant unfairly described Bernstein's conducting as:"He uses music as an accompaniment to his conducting". Similarly while Kleiber's subtly coreographed movements, facial and body gestures keeps the Concergebow players at the edges of their seats, he makes Beethoven's music sound so fresh as if it was written for him to dance to. I have watched many of the greatest conductors on film or live in concert over the last three decades but this one is totally unique for the level of enjoyment, excitement and learning one could draw from watching and hearing it over and over. I wish there were more music videos like this but there aren't many."

Great 4th and Kleiber's best Beethoven 7th.

Francisco Yanez Calvino | Santiago de Compostela, GALIZA, Spain. | 02/07/2006

(5 out of 5 stars)

"This is a very long waited DVD by all those who knew the Laser Disc with this same performances filmed live in the Dutch Concertgebouw in the `80s.

First of all we have to mention the very close relation that exist between Carlos Kleiber and Beethoven's world, specially with the Seventh Symphony he have conducted lot of times. We knew his audio recording with the Wiener Philharmoniker for Deutsche Grammophon, one of the most interesting I know, but not really so good like this, much more fresh and well done. Of course, the Wiener is an orchestra I like a little more than the Concertgebouworkest, but the Dutch one is good enough to play a fantastic concert like this, in which is easy to see everything was deeply rehearsed and prepared before going to the stage. Sometimes Kleiber even is `dancing' with the orchestra and enjoining the results of all the previous work. The tempi are fresh and light, pure Kleiber style and the sound is, like everybody use to describe, `electrifying', very passionate. Wagner said this Beethoven's Seventh is the `apotheosis of the dance' and we can say Kleiber really does it, dancing even himself with his body and swinging his baton. Probably my favourite Seventh together with very good one of Szell & Cleveland (Sony).

Sound is quite good, not excellent but good enough to be an `80s recording by Philips. You will need to rise the volume quite high but the clearness, balance and definition is good. The image is very good to, joining shots of Kleiber, the orchestra and the Concertgebouw hall, a really fantastic place in which public, enthusiastic, embrace the orchestra.

The orchestra is the smooth and very technical Concertgebouworkest, not always very fine in Beethoven (perfect in Mahler and other repertoires, even form the XXth Century Music), but with a great day here, what a woodwinds!

The Fourth is quite good too, but not so great like the Seventh. In this Fourth Symphony I really prefer Bernstein's performance with the Wiener Philharmoniker (DG).

If I'm realistic, the media of the performances would be 4 and some decimals, but as we are watching a wonderful piece of history and listening a wonderful player, it will be five.

Highly recommended.
"

Kleiber, Unlike anyone else!!!

John E. Cook | Long Beach, CA | 03/24/2005

(5 out of 5 stars)

"You have not seen conducting greatness until you have seen this man!!! Barenboim, Rilling, Szell, Thomas, Bernstein, Solti, Levine, Karajan, Rattle, and on and on....not one of these fine conductors are like the great Carlos Kleiber. So passionate about the music and orchestra in front of him he once conducted through an earthquake!!! I first saw this video in grad school in an aesthetics class. This is a must have for all serious musicians. Kleiber doesn't bother to simply beat time through these pieces, he allows the music to explode out of the orchestra. His 7th is enchanting and exciting. Buy this. Watch this and carry this man's energy into the your music making."

Carlos Kleiber Will Live Forever

C. White | Northern VA, USA | 08/02/2005

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Thanks to documents like this, Carlos Kleiber's incomparable art will live on into the future and/or as long as great music itself lives on. --Years ago, this pairing on VHS was my introduction to Carlos Kleiber "live." Over time, the tape stretched a bit, and both sound and picture suffered in those spots. The digital processing on the DVD for both audio and video is world-class, and now these performances virtually jump off the screen into your lap! What a loss this man's self-imposed retirement was to music lovers the world over. And, with his death in July 2004, he's truly lost to the world for all time.
I'm saving up to get the rest of Kleiber's "new" DGG DVDs while I still can."