Subject: I have found a DVD that I think you would enjoy
|NFL Washington Redskins - 3 Greatest Games|
For the first time, the original network broadcasts of three classic Washington Redskins games are available to own in this thrilling three- DVD set. Relive the excitement of these unforgettable moments in Redskins history... more »
QUALITY...EXCELLENT. COMPLETE?..NOT EXACTLY
E.C. | Washington, D.C. (United States of America) | 02/07/2009
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Well, the visual quality that is available on this DVD set is second to none (out of everything that has been available so far). It is very clear. Now, these sets do contain every play in these three Super Bowls (including the false start opening kickoff of Super Bowl XXVI). The footage is the same footage as the original TV broadcasts, along with commentary by the original TV game announcers. These are the strengths of the set.
The only weakness that I perceive that this set has is that the games are still somewhat edited. Some of the action between plays is edited out. So, you may see the end of a punt play, and then it might immediately cut to the next team's quarterback taking the snap, for example. So, a lot of times things that will be missing are the players going into and out of the huddle, coming onto the field, etc. In Super Bowl 26, for example, they almost completely cut out a touchdown celebration by Gerald Riggs. I imagine that for a few people, 'cutting to the chase' in this way may be preferred, but for me, these edits create a slightly artificial feel to the games on these DVDs. This is because I consider the things that were cut out to be a part of watching a football game, such as touchdown celebrations. I think it would have been better if NFL Films had released the whole game EXACTLY as broadcast on TV, except without the commercials (of course). At any rate, NFL Films should have left that stuff in, to allow you as the viewer to decide what is important enough to want to watch; if it's on the DVD, you can always fast-forward it if you don't want to watch it. But if it's not there to begin with, then you don't even have the option of watching it. If you want the whole, uncut games, you're going to have to look elsewhere.
For having the great visual quality, and every play, but also due to the edits, I give this collection Four Stars."
Is What It Is...
C. Allison | Arlington, VA USA | 11/13/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Let's be 100% clear about what this is: the 3 Super Bowl games in this set are simply the TV broadcasts of the games, as they were presented at the times (1983, 1988, 1992). No window dressing, no sugar-coating, no bells, and no whistles. While it would've been (very) nice to have included SOME highlights (or even brief mentions) of the playoff games to led up to each Super Bowl game, and definitely better to have the RADIO audio (Sonny, Sam, & Frank) versus the TV commentators, it's still a triumph to FINALLY have a copy of the Super Bowl games themselves, esp. for myself, not having a VCR back in 1983.
I hope (against hope) NFL Films will see fit to go back and retrieve the radio commentary for these games (NFLF does include snippets of radio play-by-play in every other Redskins' DVD highlight set they sell). This set is for WS fans, and I'd much rather hear the voices of my "homer" radio announcers than "objective" TV heads. Makes me ever thankful I did manage to record (VHS) the 1992 Super Bowl with both the television AND radio commentary!"
Superbowl victories not the 1982 post-season
Wilcy Moore | 07/06/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This set will include the 3 Super Bowls won by the Washington Redskins and NOT the 1982 playoff games implied by the Amazon listing. The games included are:
*Super Bowl XVII - the Redskins defeated the Miami Dolphins, 27-17, for their first NFL title since 1942.
*Super Bowl XXII - by scoring 42 unanswered points, the Redskins defeated the Denver Broncos, 42-10, for their second Super Bowl victory.
*Super Bowl XXVI - Washington won its final Super Bowl title under Coach Joe Gibbs by defeating the Buffalo Bills, 37-24."
Okay...now how about these?
Lynn A. Prather | Raleigh, NC United States | 09/26/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"It will be great to have these Super Bowl victories on DVD, but any 'Skins fan worth their salt knows that their greatest games didn't necessarily happen in the Super Bowl. Here are some suggestions for future games to release in this format:
*1972 NFC Championship v. Dallas
*1982 wk 1 v. Philadelphia
*1982 wk 7 v. NY Giants
*1982 NFC Championship v. Dallas
*1983 wk 5 v. Raiders
*1983 wk 15 v. Dallas
*1983 NFC Playoffs v. Rams
*1984 wk 15 v. Dallas
*1984 wk 16 v. Cardinals
*1985 wk 11 v. NY Giants
*1985 wk 15 v. Bengals
*1986 wk 3 v. Chargers
*1986 wk 9 v. Vikings
*1986 NFC Playoffs v. Bears
*1987 wk 11 v. NY Giants
*1987 NFC Playoffs v. Bears
*1990 wk 9 v. Lions
*1991 wk 11 v. Falcons
*1991 NFC Championship v. Lions
*2007 wk 17 v. Dallas
okay, so there are 20 games here, but I'm sure there's probably a market for 2 10-game sets. lol"