"This DVD (which I'm returning) contains a very poor, degraded copy of the Oscar-winning film, as editted, dubbed and re-titled for "The Twilight Zone." The lack of the ORIGINAL film (not repackaged for TZ), or any of the original credits makes me seriously question whether this is even an authorized release. Only the TZ-style onscreen credits remain. Very disappointing presentation of what is otherwise a beautiful film."
One of the finest adaptations of American Literature ever!
Anthony Scheinman | Forest Hills, NY USA | 07/09/2002
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This French short film, which was nominated for and WON both the Cannes Film Festival Award and an Academy Award, brings Ambrose Bierce's short story to life in a powerful way. With very little dialogue, this film, while discarding Bierce's explanation of how Peyton Farquhar was captured and sentenced to hang as a spy (and which actually is not necessary, in my opinion), depends on the visual rather than the spoken and succeeds admirably! The film may last less than half an hour, but in that time the viewer is rivetted not only by Roger Jacquet's performance as the condemned man but also by the beautiful scenery, the tight editing and just the right pacing of the action (the music, especially the slow lovely ballad "A Livin' Man", sung in the style of the Old Southern spirituals, also sticks with the viewer). The twist ending (which is worthy of the best TWILIGHT ZONE episodes [which, by the way, this film was used for in the fifth and final season of that wonderful series]), made me actually catch my breath, more than when I actually read ths original story. I heartily recommend this film not just for literature-lovers and film buffs but also for anyone with a love of the unusual and mysterious."
A GREAT FILM THAT WILL REMAIN WITH YOU FOR A LIFETIME!
Maury Haymore | Ohio, U.S. A. | 10/12/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I am 36 years old. I read the book and saw the movie when I was in the 9th grade. I am ordering the book here on line and have not seen the movie since then. The fact that I remember this story so well after all of these years should be proof enough that it is truely a work of art. It served our class as the perfect forum for discussion, and a fine example of literary expertise. Though it is a very short work, it captures all of the power, suspense and drama of a feature length film. A GREAT STORY!"
CLASSIC!
KARLOFF THE UNCANNEY | United Kingdom | 01/21/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This IS a classic short film. One that should be shown in all FILM schools/classes to students of the art of cinematic storytelling! BUT, this DVD version is disgusting! The beautiful (original)monochrone is marred by a SLOPPY tranfer. It is all but unwatchable. The people who released this version are no friends of cinema! SHAME ON YOU! This warrents a prestine viewable copy. I give this 5 stars only because I have seen it on it's first showing many years ago and the film is BEAUTIFUL! But, not in this dreadful release! Again, SHAME ON YOU releasing this crappy rip-off! Horrible!"
Great film, lousy print (unfortunately, with film the medium
Samuel Chell | Kenosha,, WI United States | 03/02/2007
(2 out of 5 stars)
"Enrico's legendary film of the Bierce short story, an adaptation arguably as good as the original, certainly deserves a print freshly struck from the original negative. The film has been used as a "textbook" introduction to cinematic techniques as well as to the uses of time in film--and moreover it's been cited as the inspiration for feature-length films such as "Donnie Darko" and the underrated but powerful "Jacob's Ladder." Unfortunately, for someone who has seen a good 16mm print, this DVD transfer is a pale imitation of how the film should look, so bad I can't bear to watch it let alone screen it for students. (If you're a jazz buff, you'll appreciate the credits, which include the expatriot American drummer and original member of the Modern Jazz Quartet, Kenny Clarke.)
There's another 25-minute French masterpiece that uses the same theme and which has acquired an even more devoted, cult-like following: Chris Marker's "La Jetée." The film takes a while longer to sink in, but upon doing so, it's unshakeable, a permanent part of the viewer's consciousness. Good thing, because the surviving VHS and DVD prints are even worse than "Occurrence"--so unwatchable as to be pointless. The copy that I recently saw was so lacking in definition and grey scale that it was impossible to discern the film's one and only moving image."